Finding Grace and Grit: My Journey Back to Amish Romance
Daily writing prompt
What book could you read over and over again?

Good day from Colorado! Out here, the sky is a brilliant, endless blue nearly 365 days a year. It’s a place where we feel deeply blessed to live in a landscape that the rest of the world chooses for their vacation.

It has been a long time since I sat down with an Amish love story. There was a time when I’d find these treasures in the $1 bin at my favorite Christian bookstore, but since COVID, that section has changed. I suspect more people turned to reading during the lockdowns, and the demand—and prices—went up.

However, price wasn’t the only thing that kept me away. A few years ago, my heart was heavy after reading about a tragic real-life case from Seymour, Missouri. In 2020, news went viral about two brothers who had committed terrible crimes against their 12-year-old sister. It was a wake-up call that shattered my naive belief that such darkness couldn’t exist within those quiet, secluded communities. For a while, I needed distance from the genre.

But recently, I found myself drawn back to a story I could read over and over again: Lilly’s Wedding Quilt by Kelly Long.

A Story of Honor and Unexpected Romance

I just discovered this is actually the second book in the A Patch of Heaven series. The heart of the story is about saving honor. Lilly Lapp makes a brave, albeit complicated, choice to lie to protect Jacob Wyse from being arrested after a misunderstanding involving a horse and a gunshot wound. That one lie led to another—an announcement that they were getting married.

Even though their marriage started as one of convenience and “saving face,” the romance that follows is beautiful. Because they married so quickly, Lilly was cheated out of the traditional quilting party. In a truly romantic gesture, Jacob organizes one for her. Seeing the community of women come together, sending patches from miles away to create a quilt for a bride they barely knew, reminds me why I fell in love with these stories in the first place.


What We Can Learn: The Take Away

Both the light and dark stories above offer profound lessons if we look closely:

Community Restoration. The quilting party is a perfect metaphor for faith and friendship. We are all “patches” from different places, but when we come together, we create something that provides warmth and comfort to those who need it most.

From the Real World: Vigilance Over Idealization. My experience with the Missouri case taught me that we shouldn’t romanticize any community to the point of ignoring human fallibility. True “inspiration” comes from facing the truth and seeking justice, not just looking at the “blue skies.”

From Lilly’s Story: The Power of Intentional Kindness. In Lilly’s Wedding Quilt, Jacob didn’t just fulfill a duty; he recognized what Lilly had sacrificed and went out of his way to restore it. It reminds us that romance isn’t just about grand feelings—it’s about noticing what someone has lost and helping them find it again.

Leave a comment

I’m Annette

Welcome. I’m so glad you’re here.

This is a space for the ‘unspoken’ stories. As a Black woman who has journeyed through childhood trauma and family alienation to find healing in God’s grace, I know what it’s like to feel lost in the shadows.

But I also know the light on the other side. Today, my life is a testimony of prayer, the joy of a second chance in marriage, and the strength of a heart reclaimed by faith. Whether you are healing from the past, navigating a diverse family, or deepening your walk with God—you are not alone. Let’s walk this path together.

Let’s connect